Art Acumen God forbid that you disagree with certain people on here. You ought to be shot for having independent thought π
By the way, you do know don't you that daring to have an opinion on here makes you a mischief maker? π
Personally I think the FPI system works OK. The vast majority of shots chosen I think are well deserved and fit in with the narrative of the site. I also think there is something that's a little bit off in terms of selection sometimes but I can't quite pinpoint what. There have been some shots recently chosen as FPIs by people who themselves are elfs or have alot of friends who are elfs, where the lighting has been flat and I'm not sure that in my opinion that they were of FPI standard but that's only my opinion and others may have different ones. But they are relatively few in comparison to the ones that I think are fully deserved.
I do think there is probably a degree of bias in some areas from what I've seen as a member for the past 3 years but it really doesn't bother me so much and I don't really understand why people get so het up over it.
If there is bias then it's probably unconscious bias. I don't buy into the suggestion that there is a witches coven of elves all sat round a fire laughing at people that don't have FPIs and awarding them out to mates, I just think in a small community where some people are extremely active socially and alot are extremely good friends with each other then some bias will slip in eventually. It's only human nature and bias happens in every aspect of life.
Fpi conversations will go on and on and on for ever eternity but I really don't see what the big deal is. My FPis were great when I got them, no doubt but they really have zero impact on my life and actually I think my photography has gotten substantially better since I got 2 of them and I use that more of an indicator than what awards have been given to me or not.
Personal pride comes from within and seeking validation from others is a sure slippery slide down to inner turmoil π
Edited by Bou Bede